Standards

Teens Without Screens

While still in high school, Logan Lane and Jameson Butler started a movement to help teens swap smartphones for more time IRL.

SCOTT ROSSI/The New York Times/Redux

Flip phones help members of the Luddite Club stay in touch.

Logan Lane and Jameson Butler have nearly identical smartphone stories. They received their first phones at age 10 and quickly found themselves spending much of their time on them—up to 10 hours a day for Jameson. “I wasn’t really living my life,” she says. “I was just scrolling.”

Both Logan and Jameson—who didn’t know each other at the time—suspected that all that screen time wasn’t good for them. “I just felt bad in my body,” says Logan. “I thought there was something wrong with me.”

Then, while high school students in New York City, both teens made a bold choice: They stopped using smartphones. After meeting and bonding over this decision, Logan and Jameson formed a network of teens working to cut down on tech use, called the Luddite Club. The name comes from Ned Ludd, an 18th-century English textile worker who destroyed automated machinery to protest the ways it disrupted his livelihood. Over time, his story has inspired others to push back against modern technology.

Since its beginning in 2021, the community Logan and Jameson created has grown. Chapters of the Luddite Club have been founded at middle and high schools across the country, encouraging young people to choose the same low-tech path.

Logan Lane and Jameson Butler have similar smartphone stories. They got their first phones at age 10. Then they quickly started spending much of their time on them. It was up to 10 hours a day for Jameson. “I wasn’t really living my life,” she says. “I was just scrolling.”

The girls didn’t know each other at the time. But each thought that all that screen time probably wasn’t good for them. “I just felt bad in my body,” says Logan. “I thought there was something wrong with me.”

Both teens made a bold choice while high school students in New York City. They stopped using smartphones. The two eventually met. They bonded over this choice. Then they formed a group of teens working to cut down on tech use. It’s called the Luddite Club. The name comes from Ned Ludd. He was an 18th-century English textile worker. He destroyed automated machinery to protest it disrupting his livelihood. His story has inspired others to push back against modern technology over time.

Logan and Jameson formed their community in 2021. It’s grown since then. Chapters of the Luddite Club have been founded at middle and high schools across the country. They inspire young people to choose the same low-tech path.

Ye Fan/The New York Times/Redux

Members of the Luddite Club, which promotes cutting down on screen time and social media use

The Phone Problem

About 95 percent of teens in the U.S. have access to a smartphone. The average teen reports spending five hours a day on social media alone. And while smartphones and social media offer instant access to information and social connections, the technology is designed to be addictive. High daily screen time has been linked to decreased physical activity and higher rates of depression and anxiety.

Jameson’s screen time hit its peak during the Covid-19 pandemic. At first, her phone helped her keep up with friends. “But, at a certain point, it was not really even about being connected,” she says. “I became addicted to short-form content.”

Logan found herself neglecting her favorite hobbies—like playing the piano, reading, and knitting—after she got a smartphone. “I would just watch YouTube or go on Instagram,” she says.

In 2021, Jameson and Logan (who hadn’t met yet) separately decided to stop using their smartphones. Initially, the goal was a temporary detox. Even that wasn’t easy. They experienced a period of withdrawal and boredom. “And people made fun of us,” says Logan. But they also felt relief as their worlds began opening back up.

About 95 percent of teens in the U.S. have access to a smartphone. The average teen spends five hours a day on social media alone. Smartphones and social media offer instant information and connections. But the technology is made to be addictive. High daily screen time has been linked to lower physical activity. It’s also linked to higher rates of depression and anxiety.

Jameson’s screen time hit its peak during the Covid-19 pandemic. Her phone helped her keep up with friends at first. “But, at a certain point, it was not really even about being connected,” she says. “I became addicted to short-form content.”

Logan found herself ignoring her favorite hobbies. They included playing the piano, reading, and knitting. “I would just watch YouTube or go on Instagram,” she says.

Jameson and Logan separately chose to stop using their smartphones in 2021. First, the goal was a short detox. Even that wasn’t easy. They had a period of withdrawal and boredom. “And people made fun of us,” says Logan. But they also felt relief as their worlds began opening back up.

Birth of a Club

It was shortly after going smartphone-free that Logan and Jameson first met at a concert. They hit it off. “I had never met another young person making an effort to be offline,” says Jameson. But at the time, they didn’t have phone numbers to exchange.

One month later, they ran into each other at their local library. “We decided to re-create that meeting every week,” says Logan. “We would just find each other at the library at 2 p.m. every Sunday.” Logan and Jameson began bringing other friends and hung posters around their schools. More teens came. The group came up with a name: the Luddite Club.

Club meetings, which often spilled over into a large park near the library, were generally low-key hangouts. The teens read books, painted with watercolors, or listened to mixtapes. The only rule was no smartphones (or similar devices) at meetings.

In late 2024, Logan and Jameson turned the Luddite Club into a certified nonprofit organization. They created a website and a print newsletter featuring art, writing, and tips for cutting down on smartphone use. “We’ve been helping people set up clubs around the country ever since,” says Jameson.

It was just after going smartphone-free that Logan and Jameson first met at a concert. They hit it off. “I had never met another young person making an effort to be offline,” says Jameson. But they didn’t have phone numbers to share at the time.

They ran into each other at their local library one month later. “We decided to re-create that meeting every week,” says Logan. “We would just find each other at the library at 2 p.m. every Sunday.” Logan and Jameson began bringing other friends. They hung posters around their schools. More teens came. The group came up with the Luddite Club as a name.

Club meetings were generally low-key hangouts. They often spilled over into a large park near the library. The teens read books. They painted with watercolors. They listened to mixtapes. The only rule was no smartphones (or similar devices) at meetings.

Logan and Jameson turned the Luddite Club into a certified nonprofit organization in late 2024. They created a website. They also printed a newsletter. It contained art, writing, and tips for cutting down on smartphone use. “We’ve been helping people set up clubs around the country ever since,” says Jameson.

SCOTT ROSSI/The New York Times/Redux

Members of the Luddite Club at a meeting in a New York City park

Life Offline

Life without smartphones was not without its challenges. “I got lost a lot,” says Jameson. Printing things that would usually be accessed through a phone, like concert tickets, was also a hassle.

But for both teens, the benefits outweighed the difficulties. Jameson started reading books again, painting, and building sculptures. Logan began writing poetry. She also rediscovered her fashion sense—one separate from social media.

The two became more physically active, riding bikes together. Their sleep improved too. Logan started getting in bed by about 8 p.m. with a book and would fall asleep by 9 p.m. Jameson had a similar experience. “My bed became a place for sleep and reading,” she says, “and not a place where I was constantly on my phone.”

Life without smartphones was not without its challenges. “I got lost a lot,” says Jameson. They had to print things usually found on a phone, like concert tickets. That was a hassle. But the pros were greater than the cons for both teens. Jameson started reading books again, painting, and building sculptures. Logan began writing poetry. She also regained her fashion sense. One separate from social media.

The two became more physically active, riding bikes together. They got better sleep too. Logan started getting in bed by about 8 p.m. with a book. She’d fall asleep by 9 p.m. Jameson had a similar experience. “My bed became a place for sleep and reading,” she says. “And not a place where I was constantly on my phone.”

SCOTT ROSSI/The New York Times/Redux

Members of the Luddite Club

A Teen Movement

Today there are more than 50 branches of the Luddite Club at high schools, middle schools, and colleges around the country. Logan and Jameson—who are now both in college—even received a letter from an elementary school student who wanted help starting a club. They happily obliged.

The club is part of a broader movement of young people who are recognizing the potential harm of social media and smartphones. Many of these teens, like Logan and Jameson, carry flip phones that offer apps like maps, Uber, and Spotify.

“We used to say that we’re not against the use of tech, we’re against the abuse of tech,” says Jameson. “But we’ve realized that it’s not really about people abusing tech. It’s tech abusing people.”

In August 2026, Meta, the social media company behind Facebook and Instagram, acknowledged the harms of its products on teens. As part of a settlement for lawsuits filed by 47 states, Meta agreed to make changes to its products, including introducing two-hour daily limits and limiting features like facial filters and likes.

“Every time you open your smartphone, you are fighting this psychological battle,” Jameson says. “I’m never going to judge or blame somebody for being hooked on their phone. I was one of the most screen-addicted youths ever.”

Today there are more than 50 branches of the Luddite Club. They’re at high schools, middle schools, and colleges around the country. Logan and Jameson even got a letter from an elementary school student. They wanted help starting a club. The teens happily agreed.

The club is part of a bigger movement. Young people are seeing the potential harm of social media and smartphones. Many of these teens are like Logan and Jameson, who are now both in college. They carry flip phones that offer apps like maps, Uber, and Spotify.

“We used to say that we’re not against the use of tech, we’re against the abuse of tech,” says Jameson. “But we’ve realized that it’s not really about people abusing tech. It’s tech abusing people.”

Meta recognized the harms of its products on teens in August 2026. Meta is the social media company behind Facebook and Instagram. It was hit with lawsuits filed by 47 states. Meta agreed to make changes to its products as part of its settlements. That includes two-hour daily limits and limiting features like facial filters and likes.

“Every time you open your smartphone, you are fighting this psychological battle,” Jameson says. “I’m never going to judge or blame somebody for being hooked on their phone. I was one of the most screen-addicted youths ever.

Get the digital lesson plan for this article

You Might Also Like:

videos (1)
Skills Sheets (3)
Skills Sheets (3)
Skills Sheets (3)
Lesson Plan (1)
Text-to-Speech