Should School Be Year-Round?

Some educators believe it’s time for all schools to swap summer vacation for shorter breaks throughout the year. Are they right?

YES

I’m sure I’m not the only student who starts losing focus this time of year. As summer approaches, many of us have more and more trouble staying motivated, and we can’t wait to throw out our books and stop thinking about school. Fast-forward a few months, and we’ve forgotten most of what we learned the year before. There has to be a better way to learn, and I believe year-round school is the perfect solution.

More than 3,000 schools in the U.S. already follow a year-round schedule, and 47 out of our 50 states have at least one year-round school. These schools usually are in session for 45 days followed by a 15-day break. The breaks are long enough for students to recharge but not so long that they lose many of the gains of the previous academic period.

In a traditional school schedule, the “summer slide,” where students forget what they learned the previous year, is a real problem. According to a study by the nonprofit academic research organization NWEA, students can lose up to 50 percent of their gains in math and reading over the summer. Even worse, the loss of learning tends to be higher for students from low-income families. Teachers may spend the first month of the new school year reviewing material, but it may be impossible for students who fall behind each summer to ever catch up. Year-round school eliminates the danger of the summer slide.

Fans of an extended summer break contend that attending a year-round school would mean missing out on fun experiences like going to camp or having a job or internship. But the only reason many of these experiences take place during the summer is because that’s when most teens are out of school. The more year-round school becomes the norm, the more options there will be for students throughout the year.

And let’s be honest—how many teens actually spend their summer break doing one thing? A lot of us go to camp or on a trip for a few weeks, then spend the rest of the summer sitting around feeling bored. In year-round school, the frequent breaks let you have a lot of experiences, without those experiences coming at the cost of your education.

NO

Last summer I had the amazing opportunity to spend nine weeks interning for a nonprofit policy-making organization. The experience sparked an interest in politics far beyond what I’ve learned in the classroom. Without the prolonged summer break, I likely would not have had the opportunity to participate in the internship, which is why I believe schools should not switch to year-round schedules. A long summer break lets students pursue their passions far more deeply than they could with just a handful of weeks off at a time.

For me, an internship proved an invaluable way to spend my summer, but there are many ways students can make the most of the extended break. Some of my friends have had jobs as babysitters and lifeguards, where they earned money for college or to contribute to their households. Other friends return to the same camp each year, where they renew friendships with teens from outside their school communities.

Proponents of year-round school may claim that extracurricular opportunities would still be available to teens who have shorter breaks interspersed throughout the year, but I disagree. Many internships and jobs require a several-month commitment, while the typical year-round school schedule gives students just a few weeks off at a time. For many companies and organizations, the logistics of onboarding new interns or workers for such a short period wouldn’t be worth the hassle. As soon as the teen got oriented, it would be time for them to go back to school.

Changing to a year-round schedule would not only prevent students from pursuing their nonacademic passions, it would also deny us much-needed extended time off. With breaks of just a few weeks, anxiety about the upcoming school session would always be in the backs of our minds. As soon as we began to truly relax, it would be time to go back to school again. Only a break that lasts the full summer gives us enough time to recharge while also engaging in our interests.

What does your class think?
Should school be year-round?
Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.
Should school be year-round?
Please select an answer to vote.
Should school be year-round?
0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.

Get the digital lesson plan for this article

Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Lesson Plan (2)
Lesson Plan (2)
Text-to-Speech